Mississippi Paper’s OpenAI Lawsuit Sent to New York Court

Share

A Mississippi newspaper chain’s copyright lawsuit against OpenAI and Microsoft is being sent to federal court in Manhattan. On Nov. 4, 2026, the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation lifted the stay on an order transferring the Emmerich Newspapers lawsuit into the consolidated OpenAI copyright case before U.S. District Judge Sidney H. Stein.

The move takes the case out of federal court in Mississippi, where it was filed on Oct. 2. It also leaves a second, similar Mississippi suit, filed by Boone Newsmedia, behind in that court for now. That suit was amended on Nov. 6.

What the transfer order says

The order is a “conditional transfer order,” labeled CTO-4. The panel’s clerk signed it on Oct. 27, according to the panel’s copy of the order. It lists one case: Emmerich Newspapers, Inc. et al. v. Microsoft Corporation, et al., No. 3:26-cv-00791, from the Southern District of Mississippi.

The order says the case involves “questions of fact that are common” to the cases already sent to Judge Stein. It sends Emmerich’s case to the Southern District of New York for pretrial proceedings “for the reasons stated” in the panel’s April 3, 2025, order, which first sent four cases to New York. That litigation is MDL No. 3143.

That transfer was not automatic. The order put itself on hold for seven days so any party could object. The panel set Nov. 3 as the deadline for oppositions, according to its docket.

The copy of the order entered on the Mississippi docket on Nov. 4 carries a clerk’s stamp with that date. It reads that “no objection is pending at this time” and “the stay is lifted.” Under the order’s own terms, the transfer takes effect once it is filed with the clerk of the Southern District of New York.

Who asked for the move

The request came from OpenAI. On Oct. 13, attorney Paven Malhotra, counsel for 10 OpenAI entities, filed a “notice of potential tag-along” with the panel, naming the Mississippi case, the panel’s docket shows. Microsoft is not listed as a filer on that notice.

Emmerich Newspapers and five other publishers filed the suit against Microsoft and those same 10 OpenAI entities. According to the 40-page complaint, the companies scraped “tens of thousands of copyrighted articles” to build ChatGPT and Microsoft Copilot without permission or payment.

The complaint calls Emmerich, based in Jackson, “one of the largest privately owned newspaper chains in Mississippi.” Its co-plaintiffs are Ojai Media, publisher of the Ojai Valley News in California, and four Coopwood companies based in Cleveland, Mississippi. The suit seeks damages and an order requiring removal of the works “from all GPT or other LLM models and training sets.”

These are allegations. None of the claims has been proven in court.

Where the case is headed

Emmerich’s case joins a proceeding that is well past its opening stage. In an order dated Nov. 12, Judge Stein referred to a motion for partial summary judgment from the “News Plaintiffs.” That group includes The New York Times, the Daily News plaintiffs, the Center for Investigative Reporting, The Intercept and Ziff Davis.

The order also set new dates. The judge wrote that the News Plaintiffs had not sought summary judgment on their “grounding and output” claims against OpenAI. They contend the issue is not ripe until a pending sanctions motion is resolved.

Stein gave them until Nov. 25, 2026, to do so, with OpenAI’s opposition due Dec. 11 and any reply due Dec. 18. Stein added that “Nothing in this Order suggests an outcome on the merits” of the sanctions motion.

The transfer order itself does not say how the Emmerich case will be scheduled inside the larger litigation. Another newspaper case gives one example. Bloomberg Law reported on July 14 that a suit led by Richner Communications was consolidated into the litigation and “will remain on hold pending resolution of motions filed in a broader case.”

How the litigation has grown

The Emmerich order adds to a short list of cases moved into the litigation from other courts. The order states that the panel first transferred four cases on April 3, 2025, and that three more have followed since. Adding Emmerich, our count is eight cases transferred in from outside Manhattan (4 + 3 + 1).

The panel’s docket shows how each of the later transfers happened, with dates from its entries:

Order Case transferred Order filed Stay lifted
CTO-1 D. Del. No. 1:25-cv-00501 May 6, 2025 May 14, 2025
CTO-2 N.D. Cal. No. 3:25-cv-05495 July 11, 2025 July 21, 2025
CTO-3 N.D. Cal. No. 5:26-cv-02730 April 9, 2026 April 17, 2026
CTO-4 S.D. Miss. No. 3:26-cv-00791 (Emmerich) Oct. 27, 2026 Nov. 4, 2026

The earlier conditional transfers on that list came from Delaware and Northern California. Other related suits were filed directly in Manhattan. Between Dec. 22, 2025, and Oct. 5, 2026, the panel’s docket logged nine such cases, by our count of its “related action” entries.

The Boone case stays in Mississippi for now

The second Mississippi suit has taken a different path so far. Boone Newsmedia, an Alabama publisher, sued Microsoft and the same 10 OpenAI entities on Oct. 30, as we reported in our story on the Boone Newsmedia lawsuit. Both suits were filed by the same three firms: Barrett Law Group, Wilson Carroll and Cuneo Gilbert Flannery & LaDuca.

Since then, Boone has filed an amended complaint, docketed on Nov. 6, according to CourtListener’s copy of the Boone docket. The amended filing itself was not available there, so its changes could not be reviewed. The docket also shows 10 “Summons Returned Executed” entries dated Nov. 11 and Nov. 17.

The panel docket entries available on CourtListener run only through Oct. 27, before Boone filed suit. They do not show whether OpenAI has asked to move that case too.

As of Nov. 20, neither Mississippi docket, as shown on CourtListener, listed an answer or a motion to dismiss from Microsoft or any OpenAI entity. The Emmerich docket’s summons returns had listed Oct. 30 as the answer date for the OpenAI entities served on Oct. 9.

Featured image: The Daniel Patrick Moynihan U.S. Courthouse in Manhattan (file photo, illustrative). Photo: Ken Lund / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0)

Rahis Saifi
Rahis Saifi
Rahis Saifi always remains passionate towards innovation and his love for gadgets has been exhibited in his writing. His knack to learn more and more had turned him too passionate towards learning. His learning attitude had shaped him as a perfect writer, He writes about technology, gadgets, blogging, smartphone tips and tricks and software reviews.
Related

Ex-Engineer Sues Palo Alto Networks Over AI Tool Credit

Ex-Palo Alto Networks engineer sues the company and CEO Nikesh Arora, alleging Unit 42 got credit for AI tools he says he built on his own time.

Boone Newsmedia Sues Microsoft and OpenAI

Boone Newsmedia alleges OpenAI and Microsoft copied tens of thousands of its articles. What the Mississippi complaint shows, and what it lacks.

Brave Sued by New York Times and Tribune Newspapers

Three Tribune papers and The New York Times sued Brave on Nov. 2, alleging its AI search, API and paywall tool copy their articles. What the suits claim.

Savannah Bananas and Shein Sued Over the Same TikTok Drum Track

LAA Music says the Savannah Bananas and Shein used its registered drum track "Boo" in social media videos without a license. A Utah travel company is suing LAA back.

Ticket Brokers File Second Lawsuit Against D.C.’s Resale Price Cap

The National Association of Ticketing Professionals says D.C.’s 10% cap on concert ticket resale prices is vague and unconstitutional.